HomeBible teachingsWhy It’s Good to...

Why It’s Good to Doubt God

A few yr in the past, I posted on my outdated web site a lecture I gave at Asuza Pacific College on the function of doubt within the Christian life. Under is a enormously abbreviated model (half the size) of that lecture that cleans up among the “oral” really feel of the unique lecture. Based mostly on suggestions I’ve acquired over the previous yr, I assumed reposting it on this kind could be of profit to some.

The Good thing about Doubt

Doubting one’s religion in God is a really robust place to be. Religion in God is what retains all of it collectively when you find yourself dealing with one among life’s many challenges issues.

Generally issues occur in our lives—it might be one huge disaster or a line of smaller issues that pile up—and also you begin having lots of doubts. At first, when you have got these disruptive ideas, you attempt to push them to the aspect, hoping they’ll simply go away, earlier than God notices.

They don’t and he doesn’t.

So you are feeling your religion in God slipping away—and it’s unsettling, disorienting, and horrifying to look at that occur. You doubt that God cares, that he’s listening; you doubt that he’s even conscious of who you might be—that he even exists.

In such a state of doubt about God, you are feeling like there may be clearly one thing very unsuitable with you.

“Perhaps I’m not sensible sufficient. Perhaps I’m a faker. Perhaps I haven’t memorized sufficient Bible verses. Perhaps I have to go to church extra usually.”

No matter it’s, you’re doing one thing unsuitable. It’s all your fault.

And so we do the one factor we have now been taught to do. We do all the pieces in our energy to get out of that state of doubt as rapidly as we will. For some, if doubt persists, they reside lives of quiet desperation, ashamed or afraid to talk up. Others merely stroll away from their religion.

Certainly, doubt is the enemy of religion, proper?

To have religion means you don’t doubt, proper?

Doubt is a spiritually damaging power that tears you away from God, proper?


There’s a good thing about doubt.

Doubt can do issues spiritually that nothing else can do.

Generally we consider our religion as a fortress—secure, comfy, acquainted. However what if God doesn’t need us to be comfy and secure? What if comfy and secure hold God at a distance?

Doubt tears down the fortress partitions to power us on a journey. It could really feel like God is way away or absent when the truth is doubt is a present of God to maneuver us to non secular maturity.

Doubt is just not an indication of weak spot however an indication of development.

Doubting God is painful and horrifying as a result of we predict we’re leaving God behind, however we’re solely forsaking the concept of God we wish to encompass ourselves with—the small God, the God we management, the God who agrees with us.

Doubt forces us to have a look at who we predict God is.

If we’re sincere, all of us suppose we’ve God found out fairly nicely. We learn the Bible and perhaps memorize a few of it. We go to church rather a lot. Perhaps even lead Bible research or one thing.

We’re doing nice, and God should definitely be impressed.

It’s so very straightforward to slide into this concept that we have now arrived—that we actually suppose we’ve obtained all of the solutions and that we nearly possess God.

We all know what church he goes to, what Bible translation he reads, we all know how he votes, we all know what films he watches and books he reads. We all know the varieties of individuals he approves of.

God occurs to love all of the issues we like. We really feel like we will communicate for God very simply.

All Christians who take their religion critically ultimately get caught up in that drawback. We start to suppose that God actually is what we occur to suppose he’s. There’s little extra value studying be taught in regards to the creator of the cosmos. No want. God is the face within the mirror.

By his mercy, God doesn’t depart us there—and doubt is God’s manner of serving to that occur.

“I would like you to die consistently.” — God

Doubt is skilled as distance from God. However that doesn’t imply that God is dying for us. Doubt indicators that we’re within the technique of dying to ourselves and to our concepts about God.

Jesus talks about that. He says, ”take up your cross” and ,”lose your life so you could find it” (Matt 10:38-39)

Paul talks about being crucified with Christ—“I now not reside, Christ lives in me” (Gal 2:20); or “You have got died and your life is hidden with Christ in God” (Col 3:3).

All that speak of dying and being crucified and hidden doesn’t describe a one-time second of conversion. It describes a required every day mode of Christian residing—the place you give up management—on a regular basis.

Dying is a traditional mode of Christian existence, and doubting is a typical approach to get the dying course of transferring. And when you find yourself in that course of, God feels far-off—however that’s when he could also be nearer to you than he ever was.

Don’t run away from doubt. Don’t struggle it. Don’t consider it because the enemy. Go by way of it—patiently… and actually… and courageously…. If you end up unsure, you might be in a interval of transformation.

Welcome it as a present—which is tough to do to in case your total universe is falling down round you. God is educating you to belief him, not your self. He means to have all of you, not simply the floor, going to church, volunteering half. Not simply the half individuals see, however the half nobody sees.

Not even you.

The Darkish Facet of the Bible

God needs you to doubt? Actually? What about John 20:31: “These items are written that you could be consider that Jesus is the Messiah, the son of God, and that by believing you might have life in his title.”

John appears to be saying, “If your Bible, you gained’t doubt however consider. So Christian, if you happen to doubt, you simply don’t know your Bible nicely sufficient. Your religion is weak. Perhaps go to at least one extra Bible examine that week.”

However consider this from one other angle. Jesus himself had his moments the place he doubted God and God was very distant from him—God deserted him—and he knew his Bible very nicely.

Within the backyard and on the cross, Jesus stated what psalm after psalm says: “God the place are you? I don’t see you anyplace. Are you even there? I’m giving up all hope.”

That one passage in John doesn’t cowl all the pieces. It simply implies that John wrote his Gospel so individuals might see how nice Jesus was and put their belief in him. It doesn’t suggest “henceforth thou shalt be an ideal religion machine and by no means doubt.”

Additionally, I don’t count on the New Testomony to say, “Doubt is God’s manner of constructing you develop.” The New Testomony doesn’t reply each query we’d have forever. It describes the early mission of the church.

The Previous Testomony is one other matter. The Previous Testomony data Israel lengthy historical past of day-to-day life with God. And the Previous Testomony writers aren’t shy in regards to the darkish aspect of their religion.

For instance, the Psalms discuss God’s distance. In almost half of the 150 psalms, one thing has gone unsuitable—some barrier has arisen between Israel and religion in God. At occasions, the psalmist feels deserted by God and he’s holding on by a thread.

One instance is Psalm 88. In abstract, here’s what the psalm says: “God, I’ve been on my knees to you evening after evening. I’m so troubled, and in a lot agony, I’d as nicely be lifeless. I’m completely with out hope…and also you don’t care. All evening and all day I name to you—I’m on my knees—however nothing. I’m in absolute ache and the one good friend I’ve is darkness.”

Be happy to name this a religion disaster.

Perhaps he doesn’t know his Bible nicely sufficient. Perhaps he must go to a different Bible examine so he can be taught you shouldn’t really feel this fashion, not to mention speak this fashion. I imply, what’s unsuitable with him and his weak religion?

This “deserted by God” expertise is within the Bible as a result of it’s valued as a part of regular Christian expertise. John Calvin stated that the Psalms are a “mirror of the soul.” Generally the soul appears like Psalm 88. In case your soul ever appears like Psalm 88, not less than know that you’re good firm.

One other instance is Psalm 73. Mainly that is what the psalm is about: “Yeah I understand how the system works: God blesses the righteous and punishes the depraved. I’ve learn the Bible. I’ve been to Hebrew faculty. I get it. My drawback isn’t that I’ve forgotten what the Bible says. My drawback is that what the Bible says doesn’t work.”

This author goes on and on about how the Bible says that God is meant to bless the devoted and punish those that will not be. However he appears round him and sees the precise reverse. The depraved and conceited, they’re wholesome, robust, they prosper. However he’s doing his greatest, and—nothing. “I’m losing my time. Why hassle? The world is smart with out you. Hey God, if you happen to had been there Donald Trump wouldn’t personal half of latest York Metropolis and homeless shelters wouldn’t be struggling for each greenback.”

The darkish locations of the Bible join with the darkish locations of our souls.

I do know lots of people raised within the church who’re like the author of Psalm 73—however they’re afraid to speak about it.

They’ve heard sermons and Bible research their entire lives the place they had been taught to consider the world in a sure “Christian” manner, after which perhaps in highschool, perhaps in faculty, they start to see that it’s extra sophisticated. Then there’s a main disconnect between what they’d been taught and what they see. Religion is now not a convincing manner of explaining the world, and they also depart it.

Whenever you really feel like that, notice that you’re proper the place so lots of the writers of the Psalms are—to not point out Ecclesiastes and Job.

Your interval of doubt has worth—to maneuver you additional on within the journey, even once you really feel such as you’ve left the trail altogether

Doubt will get you transferring.

Hearken to Some Deep Folks

Embrace the doubt. Name it your good friend. God is main you on a journey.

Religious masters of the Christian church caught on to this way back. It isn’t part of the up to date Protestant scene as a lot (with exceptions, in fact), which is a disgrace.

Many (particularly Protestant) Christians are likely to intellectualize the religion—we reside in our heads. Our religion tends to relaxation in what we all know, what we will articulate, what we will defend, how we predict. We have a tendency to position “considering” over “being” relatively than the opposite manner round.

That’s the reason doubt for individuals like us is the nice enemy. We spend lots of effort in eradicating doubt. Our world is flooded with books and apologetics organizations whose job it’s to offer the solutions rapidly and simply—no wrestle, little question—all this Jesus stuff, piece of cake.

That perspective robs us of a non secular expertise which you can’t keep away from anyway and that wiser Christians, since nearly the start of Christianity, have instructed us is important for the Christian life.

This expertise of deep doubt is usually known as the “darkish evening of the soul.” That expression has come to us by way of the writings of two sixteenth century Spanish Catholic mystics: John of the Cross and his mentor Teresa of Avila.

Many individuals have spent their lives enthusiastic about what these and different mystics wrote regarding their experiences of God. I’m not one among them, however I’m studying. Let me boil down what they’re saying.

The “darkish evening” is a way of painful alienation and distance from God that causes misery, anxiousness, discouragement, despair, and despair. All Christians expertise this ultimately—some extra intensely than others, some for longer occasions than others. However the feeling is similar: they lose their sense of closeness to God and conclude that they now not have religion. And they also despair much more.

St. John’s nice perception is that this darkish evening is a particular signal of God’s presence. Our false god is being stripped away, and we’re left empty earlier than God—with not one of the acquainted concepts of God that we create to prop us up.

The darkish evening takes away the background noise we have now created in our lives with the intention to put together us to listen to God’s voice in a while—in time, when God deems we’re prepared.

When the darkish evening comes upon us, we’re requested merely to give up to God and belief him anyway. The explanation St. John calls this a darkish evening is essential: it’s as a result of you haven’t any management over what is occurring. That could be a crucial piece in all of this, as a result of individuals need to management.

Think about, just like the Chilean miners, being on their own in a deep darkish cave, miles down, with completely not a single ray of sunshine—completely pitch black. You don’t have any concept the place you might be or the best way to get out. All is that you’re helpless. You attempt to discover your manner, you grope, however nothing. You begin strolling slowly at first, and then you definitely notice that wherever you might be, it’s huge, darkish, flat, and you may’t do something about it.

You might be uncontrolled. The purpose of the darkish evening has executed its job.

Hearken to One other Actually Deep Individual

In 1975, the Jesuit thinker, John Kavanaugh, went to work for 3 months on the “home of the dying” in Calcutta with Mom Teresa.

He was looking for a solution to some non secular stuggles. On his very first morning there, he met Mom Teresa. She requested him, “And what can I do for you?” Kavanaugh requested her to hope for him. “What would you like me to hope for?” she requested.

He answered with the request that was the very purpose he traveled 1000’s of miles to India: “Pray that I’ve readability.” Mom Teresa stated firmly, “No. I cannot do this.”

When he requested her why, she stated, “Readability is the very last thing you might be clinging to and should let go of.”

When Kavanaugh stated, “You at all times appear to have readability,” Mom Teresa laughed and stated, “I’ve by no means had readability. What I’ve at all times had is belief. So I’ll pray that you just belief God.”

The purpose of the darkish helpless place is to strip us of completely all the pieces in order that solely give up and belief stay. That’s the every day and extreme Christian calling

Are you a kind of individuals who wonders why you possibly can’t simply be a cheerful Christian like your roommate or that girl in church? Hearken to Mom Teresa. Apparently, she was in her darkish evening from 1948 till close to the time of her loss of life in 1997, with maybe some interludes in-between.

You realize all that nice issues she did? Don’t suppose her darkish evening wasn’t one way or the other related to how she spent her life. You may even say that “non secular greatness” and the darkish evening go hand in hand—it’s essential to cross by way of the one to get to the opposite. She discovered belief—not certainty—belief in God. And all of that poured out to the individuals round her.

We’ve heard this many occasions: “Let go and let God.” It’s true—however “letting go” is perhaps greater than we bargained for. We should be taught, for we won’t willingly go there ourselves.

When we’re not letting go, once we attempt to keep in charge of one thing, cling to one thing as Mom Teresa says, that’s when God turns off the sunshine and makes it darkish—not as a result of he’s towards us, however as a result of he’s for us.

Being uncontrolled is one other manner of claiming “dying to your self.” Once we are uncontrolled, that’s when God can communicate to us—with out the entire layers of stuff we have now piled up inside us. God places us out of our management in order that we will be taught to belief—like Mom Teresa stated—not “consider” or “have religion” however one thing deeper and more durable:


You possibly can solely belief when you have got let go fully, once you don’t attempt to management. Once we be taught to belief God out of our vacancy,

  • when God is out of our management,
  • when God turns into God extra deeply in us,
  • once we give up and belief,

we turn into liberated from our attachments, from our fears, and we be taught to reside with freedom and pleasure.

That’s the Christian journey.

We see this even in {our relationships} with one another. You can not have a very rising, intimate relationship with one other if one particular person is making an attempt to manage the opposite. That destroys true intimacy.

If we are attempting to manage God, what do you suppose he’s going to do? Fairly than depart the connection completely he could provoke a interval of separation, a interval of absence, a interval of darkness—in order that we will be taught that on this relationship we have now to give up, we have now to let go of management.

One can’t have contentment within the Christian life with out the darkness. Dying is the one path to resurrection, and that’s the solely manner of understanding God. There is no such thing as a shortcut. Jesus himself is our mannequin for this.

I believe that’s the coronary heart of Paul’s mysterious phrases in Phil 3:10. Realizing Christ means experiencing each the ability of his resurrection and taking part in his sufferings, being made like him in his loss of life. Demise and life. Each are a part of the Gospel life. It’s a package deal deal


When your religion has no room for doubt, then you might be simply left with—faith, one thing that takes its place in your life amongst different issues—like a job and a interest, one thing mushy and cozy.

Doubt is God’s manner of serving to you not go there.

- A word from our sponsors -


Most Popular

More from Author

- A word from our sponsors -


Read Now

The Posture of a Man of God

Main from Your Knees Jeremiah Lanphier was a businessman who served as a missionary to New York’s Decrease East Facet. He...

7 Questions That Teenagers Have to Reply

Be Alert You're a teenager: which means you're in one of the thrilling and most essential occasions of your life! I...

Dedicate Your self to Good Works Even When It’s Onerous

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQ5h2X3MjG8 ...

Crossway+ Particular: $5 Ebook of the Month (April 2024)

Ebook of the Month The $5 Ebook of the Month is an unique promotion for Crossway+ members. Every month three hand-picked...

What Temptation Is and Is Not

What Is Temptation? We should perceive sin, however we additionally want to know temptation and the way it pertains to our...

Is Individualism a Dangerous Factor?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSAIlZFEqEE ...

Amaze the Subsequent Technology with God

Give Them God (Not Moralism) I urge of you, don’t go after the subsequent technology with mere moralism, both on the...

Why Use Written Prayers? A Private Reflection

Scruples Over Written Prayers A number of years in the past, my spouse, Lindsay, and I have been requested to guide...

How Creativity Can Gas Your Worship

God the Creator The Bible opens with the story of creation. We watch God’s creation dance throughout the pages of Genesis...

4 Reminders for When You’re Damage by Somebody at Church

Getting ready for Damage within the Church We stay in a fallen world. As superb and fantastic as life within the...

10 Lesser-Recognized References to Jesus within the Outdated Testomony

Sings that Level to Jesus The Outdated Testomony accommodates “sorts,” that's, symbolic personages and issues and occasions that time ahead to...

Win the Subsequent Technology with Love

Win Them with Love The evangelical church has spent far an excessive amount of time attempting to determine cultural engagement and...